Death of a Renaissance Record-Keeper: The Murder of Tomasso da Tortona in Ferrara, 1385

  • Richard Brown

Abstract

Beginning with a description of the murder of an Italian record-keeper at the hands of an angry mob in the late fourteenth century, this essay explores the historical background of official records destruction during the Renaissance, looking beyond its fundamental purpose as the logical outcome of a bureaucratic process purely of administrative-juridical ethos. Using the example of the chancellery of Ferrara under the Este princes circa 1350-1500, it first exposes a record-keeping regime which was susceptible to all manner of bribery, corruption, and political intrigue, leading to the creation, falsification, and destruction of official documents for many reasons other than the preservation of the "public truth" following established principles and procedures. From another perspective, the essay also places records destruction in a socio-cultural context as an integral part of the annual festivities of the ceremonial city, which eventually witnessed the invention of three special public rituals of records destruction associated with significant religious commemorations. By establishing this broader socio- cultural and political background for record-keeping and records destruction, some recent archival interpretations of the medieval and early modern historical past are challenged, and questions are posed about their relevance to the theory and practice of contemporary archivy.

RÉSUMÉ

S'ouvrant sur le récit du meurtre d'un chancelier italien aux mains d'une foule en colère à la fin du xive siècle, cet essai explore les fondements historiques de la destruction officielle de documents à la Renaissance en allant au delà de son objet comme aboutissement logique d'un processus bureaucratique de nature purement administrative et juridique. À l'aide de l'exemple de la chancellerie de Ferrare à l'époque des princes d'Este (circa 1350-1500), l'article présente d'abord un régime de gestion de documents susceptible de recourir à diverses formes de corruption et d'intrigue politique donnant lieu à la création, à la falsification et à la destruction de documents officiels pour toute raison exceptée celle reliée au maintien de la « vérité publique » sur la base de principes et de procédures bien établis. D'autre part, l'essai replace la destruction des documents dans un contexte socioculturel comme partie intégrante des festivités annuelles d'un cérémonial urbain qui donnera lieu à la création éventuelle de trois rites publics particuliers de destruction des documents associés à d'importantes commémorations religieuses. En dressant ce vaste arrière-plan socioculturel et politique de la gestion et de l'élimination des documents, on remet en question certaines interprétations relatives à l'histoire des archives à l'époque médiévale et au début de l'ère moderne tout en cherchant à mesurer leur pertinence pour la théorie et la pratique archivistique contemporaine.

Author Biography

Richard Brown

Richard Brown has been an archivist at the National Archives of Canada for sixteen years, where he presently manages the Appraisal and Special Projects Section of the Government Archives and Records Disposition Division. Before coming to the National Archives, he studied Canadian history at the University of New Brunswick and civil law at McGill University. From 1975, he spent seven years pursuing post-graduate work in medieval and early modem European history in Great Britain and Italy, including research residencies at the Warburg Institute of the University of London and the Archivio di Stato Modena. He received a Ph.D. in Italian renaissance history from the University of Edinburgh in 1982. Aside from essays and papers on the modem theory of archival appraisal, Richard has written and lectured abroad about a variety of early modem historical subjects, notably on the princely court, ritual and popular festivity, and penology in fifteenth-century Italy.

Published
1997-02-13
How to Cite
Brown, Richard. 1997. “Death of a Renaissance Record-Keeper: The Murder of Tomasso Da Tortona in Ferrara, 1385”. Archivaria 44 (February), 1-43. https://www.archivaria.ca/index.php/archivaria/article/view/12195.
Section
Articles